Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Beezus andRamona
by Beverly Cleary


The Ramona Quimby series was always one of my favorites growing up. This is the first book in the series and intro
duces us to Beezus (age 9) and her "exasperating" little sister Ramona (age 4). Everything Beezus tries to do gets spoiled by Ramona's antics, from going to the library to playing chess to taking painting classes. Ramona doesn't just cause problems for Beezus, she also does crazy things like inviting her whole class to a non-existent party (and not warning her mother about it).

As an older sister, I definitely sympathized with Beezus when she worried about not always feeling good towards her sister. As a younger sister, I could really empathize with the curious Ramona, who just wanted to be grown up like Beezus. By the end of the book, Beezus has gained some insight into what it means to be a big sister as well as learning that even when you love someone, you might not like them all of the time. This is a big lesson for kids to learn, Cleary addresses the feelings of guilt that it can inspire along the way in a very sensitive way through the character of Beezus.

Some of the descriptions in this book are slightly dated, like a reference to going to the "record and phonograph store" or Mrs. Quimby washing everyone's hair in the kitchen sink. However, these old fashioned concepts really don't impact the story at all, and could be a good opportunity to explain how the world changes over time but people are basically the same. The main focus of the story is the relationship between the sisters, and it shines through brightly.

I would read this book to kids starting in first or second grade and older kids could read the later books in the series. While the language and stories would not cause comprehension issues with younger kids, I wouldn't want them to be inspired with Ramona's adventures and try to emulate them. She definitely gets herself (and others) into some scrapes!

2 comments:

  1. I have a sad confession to make: I have never read any of these books! I never realized they had so much insight about being sisters! I will definitely have to put these on my lists. I don't think you should worry to much about kids imitating her in a negative sense, I think it might just encourage them to think outside the box.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I loved Beverly Cleary when I was young!! I could always sympathize with Ramona - her sister was so mean to her at times and she really was just trying to be grown-up too. The sibling dynamic is always a great topic for books because it is so pervasive. I agree that these are books that a lot of kids can really enjoy, no matter how dated some of the references are!

    ReplyDelete